Outsourcing Development: Lifting the Veil on the World Bank Group's Lending Through Financial Intermediaries - IntroductionDownloadABOUT
The International Finance Corporation is changing the way it does business — to the detriment of people and the environment. For years, the World Bank’s private-sector arm provided loans almost exclusively to companies and projects. Now, the IFC is outsourcing the bulk of its development work to for-profit financial institutions, including commercial banks, private equity funds and insurance firms. These financial intermediaries then invested the money as they saw fit, with little apparent oversight.
The IFC has refused to disclose where most of these funds end up, so Inclusive Development International is following the money to answer this question: How does it impact people on the ground?
The investigation tackled only a small portion of the IFC’s extensive financial-sector portfolio. Yet the results were shocking. The IFC is funneling billions of dollars into some of most notorious companies and projects in the world. The problem is systemic, and not limited to just a few cases.
Inclusive Development International, in collaboration with Bank Information Center, Accountability Counsel, Urgewald, and 11.11.11 , are detailing our research findings in a four-part investigative report, Outsourcing Development: Lifting the Veil on the World Bank Group’s Lending through Financial Intermediaries.
"Disaster for Us and the Planet": How the IFC is Quietly Funding a Coal Boom - Outsourcing Development, Part 1DownloadABOUT
The first part of the Outsourcing Development series, which was released in October 2016 ahead of the World Bank Annual Meetings, examines the contribution of IFC intermediaries to climate change and the destruction of forests. The report, “Disaster for Us and the Planet”: How the IFC is Funding a Coal Boom, reveals how IFC financial-sector clients have funded at least 41 coal projects since the World Bank announced its moratorium on new coal funding. The report highlights the human toll that these projects are having on local communities, in addition to their contribution to global climate change.
Bankrolling India's Dirty Dozen - Outsourcing Development, Part 2DownloadABOUT
The second part of the Outsourcing Development series, which was released in December 2016, looks at the impacts of IFC financial intermediary lending in India. The report, Bankrolling India’s Dirty Dozen, examines the environmental and social practices of 12 of India’s largest and most reckless companies, which have received considerable financing from IFC intermediaries. Altogether IDI identified 68 projects or companies financed by six commercial bank clients of IFC whose practices appear to fall well short of its Performance Standards, and in some cases entail extremely serious violations.
Owning the OutcomesDownloadABOUT
Over the past six years, the International Finance Corporation has channelled over $50bn to the financial sector, and its long-term investments in financial intermediaries such as commercial banks and private equity funds have dramatically risen by 45 percent over that same period. However, the evidence continues to grow that this private sector arm of the World Bank Group has little control over how a great deal of this money is spent. This lack of accountability is having devastating impacts on many poor communities. The IFC must start taking more responsibility for these outcomes and ensure that its investments are benefitting, rather than harming people and the environment.
This briefing paper challenges five arguments that the IFC has put forward to justify limiting its responsibility for the environmental and social risks and impacts of these investments, and it presents eight recommendations that we believe will help the IFC move toward a more meaningful and constructive role in improving environmental, social, and human rights accountability in the financial sector.
Making Inroads: Chinese Infrastructure Investment in ASEAN and BeyondDownloadABOUT
Little more than a decade ago, China was a relatively minor actor in global investment and finance. By 2014 it had become the second largest global investor, second only to the United States. Outbound investment has been made possible due to strong backing from the Chinese state and financing from its policy and commercial banks. In recent years, China has promoted the establishment of new financial institutions and initiatives, including the multilateral Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB). China has also established investment funds such as the Silk Road Fund to provide further capital for outbound investment. These new institutions and initiatives focus heavily on infrastructure development, and China is set to expand its role in global infrastructure financing significantly in the coming years.
This publication seeks to increase public awareness of these institutions and initiatives, how they will potentially impact on local communities and the environment, and what environmental and social standards and governance systems they have adopted. It also discusses strategies that watchdog groups can deploy to respond to these developments and influence the policies, projects and operations of Chinese-led finance institutions.
IDI has also published a set of fact sheets based on the report, which are available in six languages: English, Chinese, Khmer, Vietnamese, Burmese and Thai. The fact sheets and the full report can be downloaded here:
The Demise of Accountability at the World Bank?DownloadABOUT
This article by IDI Legal Director Dr. Natalie Bugalski examines recent trends in the accountability system at the World Bank, including the new Environmental and Social Framework and developments at the Inspection Panel, through the lens of involuntary resettlement. The article explores the trend away from clear policy entitlements and protections for project-affected people towards negotiated risk management and redress in the case of harms, and analyzes what it means in practice for the protection of human rights in cases of displacement. The analysis of the ESF is done through a ‘road-testing’ of the framework on a hypothetical hydropower project, while the Inspection Panel section delves deeply into the ‘Early Solutions’ pilot in Lagos, Nigeria. The article was published in the American University International Law Review (Volume 31, Issue 1) in August 2016.
An Evaluation of the Inspection Panel's Early Solutions Pilot in Lagos, NigeriaDownloadABOUT
In early 2014, the World Bank Inspection Panel added a new tool to its operating procedures known as the “Early Solutions approach.” Through this process, the Panel plays a passive problem-solving role, giving the World Bank and project affected people additional time to resolve grievances before the Panel decides whether or not to register the Request for Inspection. The Early Solutions approach was first piloted in a case in Lagos, Nigeria in which some 9000 people were forcibly evicted from the Badia East urban poor settlement. This report by IDI and the Centre for Research and Multinational Corporations (SOMO) evaluates the fairness of the process used in Lagos and whether the outcomes were in the best interests of affected people and consistent with World Bank safeguard policies. The report makes recommendations for improving institutional accountability whilst ensuring the provision of effective remedies to people harmed by World Bank-financed projects.
Glass Half Full? The State of Accountability in Development FinanceDownloadABOUT
This ground-breaking report authored by IDI and 10 partners documents the obstacles that communities and workers must overcome in order to seek recourse from development finance institutions. The report shows data from 758 complaints since 1994 and assesses the extent to which these institutions and their accountability offices are equipped to meaningfully address these complaints. It finds that, even though complainants are better off than they would be in the absence of any complaint procedure, the outcome rarely provides adequate remedy for the harm that people have experienced. It sets forth a range of specific recommendations for improvement so that project-affected people receive the respect and remedy that they deserve.
The Suffering of Others: The Human Cost of the International Finance Corporation’s Lending through Financial IntermediariesDownloadABOUT
Increasingly, development money is being channelled through third parties such as banks or private equity funds. The world’s leading proponent of this financing model, the International Finance Corporation, spent $36bn this way in just the four years leading up to June 2013. But what does this ‘hands-off’ form of development financing mean for people? Are the risks to communities and their livelihoods just too high given the weaker social and environmental protections entailed? This report by Oxfam, IDI and ten other NGOs tells the human story behind the high finance and statistics, and asks whether reforms to this model of lending have gone far enough to protect communities.
Human Rights and the World Bank: Lessons from IDA CountriesDownloadABOUT
World Bank projects have significant impacts on human rights. The Bank narrative cites ways in which Bank projects contribute to the realization of human rights such as, “access to health, education, food and water, promoting the participation of indigenous peoples in decision-making and the accountability of governments to their citizens, supporting justice reforms, fighting corruption and increasing transparency of governments.” However, the accounts of civil society and communities affected by IDA projects tell a different story. Many Bank projects have clear winners and losers—and all too often the poorest and most vulnerable end up on the losing side.
This IDI and Bank Information Center (BIC) publication outlines several cases where the World Bank has used IDA funds in ways that threaten the human rights of the most vulnerable people in the world’s poorest countries. The cases, in Africa, Asia and Central Europe, show how loopholes, gaps and deficiencies in the current suite of safeguard policies can lead to impoverishment and serious violations of human rights when, for example, people are displaced, children are forced to work and people with disabilities or indigenous communities are not meaningfully consulted. The cases also show how gaps in the safeguards can lead to environmental damage including unnecessary contribution to climate change.
Bittersweet Harvest: A Human Rights Impact Assessment of the EU's Everything But Arms Initiative in CambodiaDownloadABOUT
The European Union’s Everything But Arms (EBA) scheme provides preferential access to the European market for all products except arms and ammunitions from all countries classified by the United Nations as ‘least developed’. While EBA is intended to benefit the poor through job creation from export-led growth, the case of Cambodia’s rapidly expanding sugar industry tells a different story. In September 2013, IDI and Equitable Cambodia published Bittersweet Harvest, a human rights impact assessment of the EBA initiative and the sugar industry it has spawned in Cambodia.
Bittersweet Harvest is based on interviews with over 275 people, including local officials, human rights workers, community leaders and small holder farmers from Koh Kong, Kampong Speu and Oddar Meanchey provinces who have been impacted by EBA-driven industrial sugar development. The assessment finds that, in the absence of effective human rights safeguards, Cambodia’s policy of granting large-scale land concessions to private investors for agro-industrial development and the EU’s policy of granting preferential tariffs to spur such investment in least developed countries both carry risks of devastating human rights impacts. These risks have materialized in forced evictions and land seizures that have been part and parcel of the development of Cambodia’s sugar industry. As a result, affected people suffered a severe rollback in their enjoyment of basic human rights, including the rights to adequate food, water and housing, as well as the right to work, the right to education and the right to health.
A Discussion Paper on a Human Rights Approach to Development of Cambodia’s Land SectorDownloadABOUT
In 2012, IDI Legal Director Natalie Bugalski authored a Discussion Paper on a Human Rights Approach to Development of Cambodia’s Land Sector for Bridges Across Borders Cambodia and the Heinrich Boll Foundation. The paper offers a rationale for adopting a human rights approach to development and recommends a ten-pronged framework for adopting the approach in the land sector. The framework aims to shift power to Cambodia’s citizens and increase accountability of decision-makers and power-holders, through processes and tools that elevate support to marginalized and vulnerable groups, access to information, transparency about decision-making, and accountability including the redress of harms. It also promotes methods for designing and implementing smarter strategies for development partner interventions to contribute to positive human rights change.
DERAILED: A Study on the Resettlement Process and Impacts of the Rehabilitation of the Cambodian RailwayDownloadABOUT
In 2012, IDI Legal Director Natalie Bugalski co-authored a report for Bridges Across Borders Cambodia that reviews the resettlement process and impacts of the ADB and AusAID-financed Rehabilitation of the Cambodian Railway Project. The report, DERAILED, describes the policy and international human rights law obligations meant to protect the rights of the 4000 resettled families and provides evidence of how these obligations are being flouted in practice. The principal findings of the report are that resettled families have faced threats and intimidation during the process precluding the possibility of meaningful consultation; compensation amounts have been well below the cost of building a minimally adequate house in Cambodia; resettlement sites have been too far away from sources of livelihood and have not been properly prepared with basic services and facilities, including water and schools; household income levels have fallen upon resettlement and the resulting unmanageable debt burdens have created a risk of impoverishment, homelessness and landlessness. The report contains an extensive list of recommendations to the Cambodian government, the ADB and the Australian government.
Evictions and Resistance in Cambodia: Five women tell their storiesDownloadABOUT
In 2011, IDI Legal Director Natalie Bugalski coordinated and authored a publication for Amnesty International called Evictions and Resistance in Cambodia: Five women tell their stories. Through poignant and beautiful photos by Todd Brown and words by Natalie, the publication traces the lives of five Cambodian women, Hong, Mai, Sophal, Heap and Vanny who have faced or continue to resist forced eviction from their homes and land. Forced evictions frequently lead to the breakdown of community networks and informal support systems relied upon by women in their daily lives. They often mean disruption of children’s education, diminished access to health services and a deterioration of the family’s mental and physical well-being. Because many victims of forced eviction are resettled in areas far from urban centers and work opportunities, husbands spend long stretches of time away from their families, leaving their wives to cope alone with daily household chores and family needs. Nonetheless these women have developed coping strategies for themselves and as the primary caregivers for their family. The women whose stories are told have faced forced eviction, or continue to resist eviction and removal from their land, with a mix of fear and bravery, anger and calm resolve.
Post-conflict Housing Reconstruction and the Right to Adequate Housing in Timor-LesteDownloadABOUT
In 2010, IDI Legal Director Natalie Bugalski authored a background paper for the Special Rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living, Raquel Rolnick for her report to the Human Rights Council’s sixteenth session on post-disaster and post-conflict situations. Five experts were commissioned to provide background papers on various post-disaster and post-conflict contexts. Natalie was asked to provide a paper on Post-conflict Housing Reconstruction and the Right to Adequate Housing in Timor-Leste.
In 2006, just four years after Timor-Leste became an independent nation, civil strife broke out in the streets of its capital, Dili, and spread to the districts, leading to the displacement of some ten to fifteen percent of the population. This paper explores this episode of conflict, known as “the crisis”, and seeks to distil lessons about the way in which housing and land rights violations – and the failure to address them– feed into cycles of displacement, dispossession and conflict. An analysis of the causes and housing rights implications of the conflict elucidates the repercussions of weak and incomplete responses to earlier conflict and displacement. An examination of the response to the 2006/7 conflict offers insights into the extent to which key actors took into account lessons learnt from previous experience and designed and implemented a program that both addressed immediate housing rights concerns and aimed to prevent a recurrence of violence, destruction and displacement.
The Grand Theft of Dey KrahormDownloadABOUT
In 2010, IDI Managing Director David Pred authored a chapter in a Land Research Action Network publication on Land Struggles, called The Grand Theft of Dey Krahorm. The chapter tells the story of an inner-city Cambodian community’s struggle to prevent the grand theft of their land. In 2003, the Cambodian government announced that 100 inner-city poor communities would be provided with secure land tenure and full basic services. Dey Krahorm, in Phnom Penh, was to be among the first. However, the land was subsequently stolen from the local residents by a private company, in collusion with a handful of leaders. Six years later, the community was forcefully evicted from their homes, with the aid of police and other armed government forces. The still undeveloped land is now being offered for sale by the company at an enormous profit. The chapter movingly describes the traumatic experience of forced eviction of Dey Krahorm residents that took place in January 2009.
Formalizing Inequality: Land titling in CambodiaDownloadABOUT
In 2010, IDI Directors David Pred and Natalie Bugalski co-authored a chapter in a Land Research Action Network publication on Land Struggles, called Formalizing Inequality. The chapter examines Cambodia’s multi-donor supported land-titling program and looks at why, despite its goal of reducing poverty by improving land tenure security, it has failed to protect the legal rights of many of those most vulnerable to forced displacement. It explores the case of Boeung Kak Lake and the denial of residents’ rights when they were excluded from the land adjudication process and made subject to forced eviction as the lake was filled by a private developer. The chapter also describes the community’s action to bring a case to the World Bank Inspection Panel and demand accountability.